Should we show attribution for UP votes?

0

Maybe we should show who upvoted a question or answer (similar to Quora).

Why we should:

  • Extra way for people to be visible on the site. Even if someone isn't asking or answering, they can be visible with their votes.
  • Incentive to vote. If I see a great answer, I would want to be associated with it by voting (even if I don't have a comment to make).

Why we shouldn't:

  • Some people might want to vote anonymously.
last edited Mar 13 '14 at 07:45
added Mar 13 '14 at 07:44
Blank
Chrissie Gray
1,107 points
  • My opinion: being able to vote anonymously outweighs the social and visibility benefits. Lets wait to see how everyone feels about this one. It's a really good feature to discuss! – Nishank Khanna 10 years ago
  • I think I could be convinced otherwise, but my gut reaction is that this is better to leave anonymous. The people who really want to brag about how supportive they are of a question or answer I think will have a tendency to leave a comment as well. – rbwhitaker 10 years ago
  • Personally, I do believe in transparency over anonymity. I seem to recall that this was a rank privilege on the former SE platform. Does following this method push the discussion one way or the other? – Nick Stevens 10 years ago
Add Comment

STAGE: Discussing

This item is being discussed by the community. Vote up if you want it and add your opinion in the comments.

We'll set it as planned once it's been decided how we're going to implement it.

Stats

Viewed 1.35K times

Added 10 years ago

 
 
Back to Roadmap