MySQL and PostgreSQL licence issue


-1

Our company wants to use MySQL for one software product, and our product is not open-source. Is it legal to use it freely?

If not, how about PostgreSQL? Is this okay for our purpose?

License Open Source

asked Jul 18 '11 at 13:31
Blank
Josh Morrison
102 points

4 Answers


3

Do you want to distribute the product? If yes, do you want to bundle MySQL? Then the GPL isn't too clear about that point. Is it now statically linking or not? I guess no one really knows the answer to that.

If, however, you don't bundle it with your product and the user has to download it themselves, you should be fine, even with the GPL, since you are not distributing a GPL product.

If your product is a web application, so you aren't distributing any code at all, then you are fine. There is actually a special version of the GPL, Affero GPL (AGPL), which closes that loophole. With the AGPL you have to distribute any modification made to a AGPL product, even if you aren't technically distributing your product.

If you want to be totally safe, use PostgreSQL, since PostgreSQL is licensed under the PostgreSQL License (which is a BSD /MIT style license), and you should be fine.

But to be really safe, ask a lawyer and let him decide.

answered Jul 18 '11 at 21:37
Blank
Andreas Arnold
131 points
  • how about developing a POS System ? – Raju Gujarati 7 years ago

2

At this point, I think it's difficult to provide you with a "sure answer".

It used to be common understanding that you cannot distribute a product containing GPL software without GPL-licensing the product itself.

In recent years, I have seen so many interpretations and counter-interpretations (what's distribution? is there a difference between statically-dynamically linked libraries?) that I cannot honestly give a general answer anymore. Many of these discussion are also summarised at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GNU_General_Public_License Ideology aside, it is my opinion that the GPL license is one of the worst licenses ever written. It's verbose, ambiguos, with a ridiculous "ideological" preamble.
The central concept of distribution is never defined in the license, leaving the reader with many question (is distribution when a contractor create the software for his customer? Is it distribution when ACME Germany gives the software to ACME Italy? Is it distribution when the Bank IT Dept install a software in all Bank's branches?)

All in all, I think the only safe option to use GPL software (and MySql) is to use it for in house projects. That's, by the way, the common use case of MySql. If you want to package it and sell it to customers as part of a bigger project, you'll easily get into trouble.

Note that all this discussion does not apply to PostgreSQL. PostgreSQL is licensed under a BSD/MIT-type license, and therefore can be used, modified and distributed without any license issue.

answered Jul 18 '11 at 19:55
Blank
Filippo Diotalevi
2,573 points

1

If you can't answer this yourself by understanding the licences, you need a lawyer.

Did you even try to read the licences in question?

answered Jul 19 '11 at 00:21
Blank
Marcin
526 points

0

If these answers are not satisfying, you might take a look at the Firebird Database. Its license is explained in the Firebird Wikipedia entry:

The Firebird database engine and its modules are released under an
open-source license, the Initial Developer's Public License (IDPL), a
variant of the Mozilla Public License (MPL). It does not force the
developer to open the products using Firebird or even
custom-derivatives made from its source code; but if the developer
chooses to do so, then some terms and conditions should be honored.
The IDPL gives the developer the freedom of making propietary, closed
source applications that use Firebird or are based on it

So far as capabilities go, the database is transaction driven, includes Views, Stored Procedures and Triggers, is very SQL 92 compliant, can be run in a client server mode or embedded and is apparently handling some databases in the wild with sizes of 50 to 100 GB.
answered Jul 19 '11 at 00:47
Blank
Jack Rodenhi
607 points

Your Answer

  • Bold
  • Italic
  • • Bullets
  • 1. Numbers
  • Quote
Not the answer you're looking for? Ask your own question or browse other questions in these topics:

License Open Source