We're doing some hiring at a very high level for a VP Marketing candidate and I'm aware of the general advice that it's best to network into folks for roles like these (we had lots of success doing that for our VP Engineering last year).
However, I've heard good things about job posting sites like TheLadders and Startuply, but wondered if anyone here has experience/recommendations about whether these bring high value applicants. We're looking for an extremely specific person (multiple years experience with a SaaS/subscription revenue startup, scaling a small team to a bigger one, growing from low millions to high tens of millions in revenue).
I'm certainly working hard on the networking angle, but don't want to leave any stones unturned that might be worthwhile.
Especially for specialist, I never had good luck with any of the usual sites. Every time I did it, I got swamped with a lot of garbage.
That said, you are much better off diving into SaaS events and networking there. It will take time. If you need someone sooner, you need to sniff out a good specialist recruiter. Again, just like with candidates, market is swamped with the worst of the worst garbage. When you meet the right one though, you will know.
Out of hundreds of recruiters I have met, there are only 3 I would ever call or pick up their calls.
Also, don't forget the "unusual" candidates. There are lots of women who have some impressive credentials from SaaS industry. They chose to leave the workforce for couple of years, but they are ready to get back into it. You can pick up some talent for very reasonable compensation you would NEVER be able to find through regular "passive job seeker" market.
At the end of the day, anything but networking is just a poor crutch. There is no substitute for good 'ol relationships. And that takes time.