I'm afraid someone's patenting my ideas


2

I had a brainstorming session with a friend a year and a half ago, and a lot of great ideas came out of it. I moved on the ideas, starting a company - our product has been on the market for about 10 months now. I invited him to join me at the outset, but he declined.

In the last two or three months, he's launched a competing product with a lot of the same ideas. At the bottom, it says, "patent pending." I asked him if he was patenting any of the ideas that we talked about, or that my product has already implemented and released, and he was vague. "Friends don't litigate friends," he wrote.

So. Do I need to do anything? Can I find out what patents he's applying for? Is it too late to document that I had these ideas too? Is it enough to beat him to market with a feature, or can he patent something that he hasn't released yet?

Patent Intellectual Property

asked Sep 9 '11 at 03:24
Blank
Riley
193 points
  • I swore I saw that "patent pending" on a site before. Do you mind telling me the site? – Shawn Mclean 9 years ago

3 Answers


5

Ok, here's my best answer (I have some grounds to answer since I was a target for a patent lawsuit):

How much money can your friend spend on useless litigation? If he does not have more than $100K in disposable income, forget everything about the patents and just proceed to build the best product you can, sign up the most customers you can and grow your business. You can safely ignore him and beat him fair and square where it matters, in the market.

In the unusual case where your friend is a rich idiot... I probably wouldn't change my tactics. The fact that your product has been out in public for 10 months is enough to establish prior art. Maybe just make sure you can prove that your product existed at a certain date.

You do understand that no matter what, even if he did file for a patent, it will take 2 to 4 years before he could ever sue you. Where will you be in 4 years? Most likely, your product will either be dead, or have pivoted to something so different that all of this discussion is moot.

answered Sep 9 '11 at 04:47
Blank
Alain Raynaud
10,927 points

2

I'm not going to give you legal advice here, because obviously this is a site for startups and not jurisprudence. But I would ask a few questions here.

First, just how novel is your idea? How sure are you that you and he are the first people to think of this? If you weren't the first (and no disrespect, you probably weren't), and someone has something resembling prior art out there, then it doesn't matter.

Second, do you believe he is really applying for a patent? He might just be full of it, and think that phrase on his page impresses people. It's not that easy to do, and it ain't free, so what are the chances he really is? I would venture to guess that any twit who would drop a phrase like, "friends don't litigate friends", has delusions about becoming Mark Zuckerberg or something and having Google buy his awesome product.

Thirdly, say you really believe you do have a novel idea, and really believe he is patenting it. Go straight to a patent lawyer, and get advice on this. Don't ask anyone else's opinion, go straight to an expert. He/she will tell you how to properly handle this, and if you could successfully litigate. Patent law is so crazy, amateur advice might screw up any chance you have of challenging him.

Most likely, the whole patent thing is moot; neither of you could patent it, someone already has the necessary IP and you couldn't afford to challenge infringers anyway. So stop worrying about it, and if you're a product guy and not just an idea guy, build the product and beat him. So what if he beats you to market; figure out his product's weakness and beat him. I don't mean to be trite, but end users buy products, not ideas for products.

answered Sep 9 '11 at 04:20
Blank
Craig Saboe
423 points

-2

I'm not a lawyer so I can't answer for any legal sides of this question. But I do have a couple of suggestions.

  1. Check out Google Patent Search ( http://www.google.com/patents )
  2. Patents are expensive to file, a few thousand dollars. Apply for
    what's called a Poor Mans Patent for now. As in today. Burn all your
    documents into a non-re-writable cd-rom. Take this CD-rom along with
    any paper documents you have to the post office. And tell them to
    give you an envelope where you can store these items and have them
    put a certified seal on it. Do not open the envelope under any
    circumstance unless in front of a judge. Just go to the post office
    and tell them you want a poor mans copyright/patent and they'll know
    how to handle it. It's 50 cents as opposed to whatever a patent
    costs. It probably does not offer the ultimate protection. But you
    should do this to have something at least.

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poor_man's_copyright

answered Sep 9 '11 at 04:27
Blank
Chamilyan
353 points
  • Bad advice: you are confusing copyright and patent. The method you describe is for copyright. It accomplishes nothing for patents. – Alain Raynaud 9 years ago
  • Like I said, I'm not a lawyer. It's not patent protection I'm describing. It's an idea to do something cheaply to have something that he can store away. I did this for my business before we got patent pending status and it was recommended to us by a patent lawyer. So I don't know what your talking about. – Chamilyan 9 years ago
  • btw I like your equity calculator Alain :). Iv'e been recommending it in other answers. – Chamilyan 9 years ago

Your Answer

  • Bold
  • Italic
  • • Bullets
  • 1. Numbers
  • Quote
Not the answer you're looking for? Ask your own question or browse other questions in these topics:

Patent Intellectual Property